| Dont
Let the Good Ones Get Away |
vol-un-teer
- n. 1. A person who performs or gives his services of
his own free will..
Red Cross workers; certain firemen; Boy Scout troop leaders. These
are the types of people we typically think of as volunteers. But whether
you realize it or not, this term can also be used to accurately describe
your best and brightest employees.
You know who they are - that select group of people working for your
company who are so skilled, they could work almost anywhere they chose.
Have you ever stopped to think why these superstars stay working for
you?
Turnover can devastate an organization. But what can you do to keep
your employees from "jumping ship?" This article addresses some of
the primary factors leading to turnover, and suggests some great ideas
for motivating and retaining your best employees.
| Factors
Leading to Turnover |
Turnover is a
source of major anxiety for managers. When employees quit, supervisors
are left to wonder what they could have done to keep their staff happier.
Many managers immediately point to money as the culprit behind employee
turnover. But experts warn that increasing compensation alone won't
improve loyalty. When an employee is already dissatisfied with his
or her job, increasing compensation may only cause more stress. Ultimately
this stress, combined with feelings of guilt, can cause an employee
to quit.
To reduce turnover, you must first seek to understand the primary
causes behind it. Here are a few of the most common reasons cited:
Significant Change - In an organization,
change can take many forms. Events like mergers, acquisitions and
reengineering breed insecurity among employees. They may not fully
understand or accept their new responsibilities, and may even question
their future with the company.
Likewise, changes in management may also cause turmoil. Employees
with a history of loyalty to one manager may not necessarily feel
as loyal to another. Factors such as a manager's personality and management
style can wield a strong influence over employees' motivation and
performance.
Bottom line, change is threatening. If not handled properly, it can
lead to job dissatisfaction and turnover. When people are threatened,
their immediate reaction is to run
|
"When
people are uncertain about what's going to happen to them,
they tend to run."
- Don Robinson, Manager, Pritchett & Associates.
|
Poor Hiring Practices - When filling
a position, hiring authorities often prepare a description detailing
the duties of the job. They look for candidates who have the proper
qualifications, and all but ignore psychological and behavioral factors
which influence performance.
When you hire someone, you are hiring more than just qualifications.
You are really hiring the candidate's behavior. If a person's behavioral
traits do not fit well with your corporate culture, that employee
is likely to experience difficulty performing at an acceptable level.
Turnover is the most common result .
Lack of Challenge or Opportunity - For
true professionals, fulfillment lies in the work itself. As a rule,
knowledge workers thrive on exciting projects that challenge their
abilities. Not surprisingly, if forced to choose between challenging
work in an average environment, or mundane work in an outstanding
environment, most skilled employees will lean toward the challenging
work.
While it's nearly impossible to make every day of work an adventure,
managers sometimes overlook the importance of providing ongoing opportunity
for their employees. If employees become bored or complacent, they're
more likely to begin looking elsewhere .
Bureaucracy and micro-management - Today's
worker is intolerant of bureaucracy. When professionals believe the
time and energy required to manage work is greater than the time they
have for the work itself, productivity plummets and frustration soars.
Understandably, employees dislike the thought of too many meetings,
or bosses who supervise too closely. Control like this violates their
sense of independence and professionalism.
Management ignores factors other than money
- While money is an important factor in motivating employees,
it is not the only one. Often factors inside a company like recognition,
time off, trust, quality of management and opportunities for growth
influence employees' career decisions.
When an organization ignores the importance of these emotional factors,
it may force employees to look outside the company for sources of
motivation. And if satisfactory compensation becomes difficult to
achieve, these employees are more likely to quit.
Given the fact that
coercion is not an option, what can you do to retain the good employees
you have? The remainder of this article addresses this very question.
| Improving
Employee Retention |
Improve
your hiring process - Some experts estimate that 75% of
managers' efforts to prevent turnover should focus on improving the
hiring process. This is based on the assumption that bad hires are
the primary cause of turnover. In the grand scheme of things, you
either pay now and develop a well-planned recruitment and selection
process, or you pay later by using a hit-and-miss process which may
translate into higher turnover rates.
One key to making better hiring decisions, and reducing turnover,
is to focus on behavioral traits. This is a term used to describe
how a person thinks, acts, behaves or interacts with others. When
you hire someone, you are really hiring his or her behavior.
Every position within a company requires different behavioral traits.
For example, good supervisors, managers, executives or sales people
share a number of traits, such as:
|
Assertive
- they are straightforward; they make things happen and get
them done.
|
|
Relating
- they know how to work well with others.
|
|
Achieving
- they have a strong desire for independence and recognition.
|
|
Integrity
- they earn the trust of others.
|
To improve your selection process, consider incorporating behavioral
hiring concepts. Before recruiting candidates, make a list of behaviors
that benchmark for success in the available position - a behavioral
profile. To get an idea of which traits to include in your profile,
examine the behavior of your top employees in that type of position.
When your profile is complete, use structured interview questions
to examine trait information.
If you require additional assistance in developing a behavioral profile
or structured interview, a staffing service or other hiring expert
will be able to provide assistance.
Make Work Challenging - As leader,
it's the manager's obligation to identify opportunities for making
work more exciting and meaningful. Creating these opportunities is
challenging, at best. To generate ideas, form a users group of your
best customers. Bring them together with your top employees to cultivate
new applications, products or services. For knowledge workers, the
challenge of bringing these ideas to fruition will make going to work
exciting.
Minimize Red Tape - Remove management
burden from employees by keeping roles and processes streamlined:
|
Avoid
elaborate project documentation. Make sure any reporting or
other record keeping is really necessary
- if you won't refer back to the information, don't keep track
of it.
|
|
Keep
meetings focused on pre-planned agendas. This will make meetings
shorter and task-oriented.
|
|
Involve
only the parties critical to accomplishing a specific task.
Skilled employees' time is much better
spent doing work as opposed to managing it.
|
Develop a formal plan to manage change -
When you're looking to make a small change, it can often
be done with only minor problems. But when change requires a major
paradigm shift, it can cause a high degree of trauma - especially
in an organizational setting.
When you anticipate a major change in your organization - be it an
acquisition, change in management, or internal restructuring - you
must develop a plan to ensure good employees do not wind up "casualties
of war."
In essence, you need to implement a plan to "re-recruit" your staff,
using the same amount of energy and commitment you'd use to bring
on a new recruit. To retain key employees, a good plan should address
the most important questions they are likely to ask, such as:
|
Whom
exactly will I work for?
|
|
Will
this change affect my compensation or daily responsibilities
in any way?
|
|
Will
our products or services change at all?
|
|
When
will this change take place?
|
|
What's
in it for me?
|
By anticipating questions like these, and providing adequate answers,
you can allay the fear, insecurity and stress your employees will
experience. The more positive the experience, the less likely your
employees will be to leave.
Provide frequent rewards and recognition
to motivate employees - Results of a recent survey by the
Council of Communication Management confirm what almost every manager
already knows - recognition for a job well done is the top employee
motivator. But what motivates one employee may not necessarily motivate
another.
To effectively use recognition and rewards as a means of improving
retention, you must first match the reward to the person. Start by
finding out the individual's personal preferences, and reward him
or her in a way he or she truly finds rewarding. In addition, the
reward or recognition must be timely and specific. It must be given
as soon as possible after the behavior or achievement to have the
desired effect.
|
"Any
time you make people feel better about themselves, you are
building strong motivation." Rebecca Boyle, Manager Training
Services, Empire of America.
|
Guidelines for rewards and recognition -
When designing a reward and recognition program, keep the
following guidelines in mind:
|
The
program should be in line with your company's values and business
strategy.
|
|
Employees
should participate in the program's development and execution.
|
|
Since
what is meaningful to one employee may not be as meaningful
to someone else, the program should
include some variety.
|
|
The
programs should be highly visible and public.
|
|
The
programs should be easy to implement, and should be changed
frequently.
|
A quick-hitting list of no-cost and low-cost
motivators:
-Call an employee into your office just to thank him or her - don't
discuss any other issue.
-Coordinate a surprise celebration of the achievements of an employee
or group of employees.
-Give an outstanding employee a three day weekend.
-Send birthday cards signed by the CEO to your employees' homes.
-Acknowledge individual employees' achievements by using their names
when preparing status reports.
-Develop a "behind the scenes" award, specifically for employees who
are not usually in the limelight.
-Name a continuing recognition award after an outstanding employee.
-Wash the employee's car in the parking lot during lunch.
All of these suggestions relate to a key concept mentioned earlier
- often the best ways to motivate and retain employees have nothing
to do with money! Forms of recognition such as these go way beyond
the power of cash. They tie employers and employees emotionally, and
foster stronger interpersonal relationships within the company. These
ties go a long way in promoting employee loyalty.
Foster professional development of your staff
- In reality, most employees want to work for managers
who challenge them and develop their talents. People are less likely
to leave organizations where they know managers really care about
their development. This may sound "touchy-feely," but non-monetary
factors such as professional development play an important role in
promoting loyalty.
Use emotional and other non-monetary motivators to your advantage,
by making professional development an integral part of your operations.
Consider the following:
|
Offer
tuition reimbursement as a performance incentive. Pick up
the tab for course work related to
an employee's current job or desired career path.
|
|
Send
top performers to seminars or workshops outside the company
that cover topics they are interested
in. Allow these employees to hone their skills in areas where
they feel they need the most help.
|
|
Provide
employees with literature, videos or tapes related to your
business. Help keep them on top of
the latest trends in your industry. You may even want to set
time aside to review these materials
and exchange ideas on what you've learned.
|
Obviously, these suggestions will make your employees better qualified
to perform their jobs. But what some managers don't realize is that
investing in professional development is highly motivating for employees.
Devoting time and money to professional development shows employees
that management is willing to invest in their future. It conveys to
an employee a sense of worth well beyond the weekly paycheck.
Reward longevity - This suggestion
is not universally popular. Many employers would argue that you should
never reward longevity - only performance. This may be true from a
productivity standpoint. But when it comes to reducing turnover, it's
important that your staff realizes you value loyal employees.
These rewards can take many forms, from an engraved pen to additional
paid vacation. Whatever incentive you choose, make sure you celebrate
employment milestones publicly - you want your entire staff to know
how much you appreciate loyalty .
This entire article
has focused on ways to reduce employee turnover. But, not all turnover
is necessarily bad. In fact, some managers even encourage it. What
are the upsides to turnover?
|
New
employees can bring fresh ideas to a company. They can bring
positive experiences and new perspectives
to the table.
|
|
Not
all employees who leave a company are top performers who quit.
As upset as managers can be about
losing a great employee, they can be just as ecstatic about
being free of a lousy one.
|
|
Without
turnover, an organization can suffer from stagnancy, boredom,
and complacency. New employees can
make it easier for management to implement much needed
changes.
|
So what is a healthy amount of turnover? Only you can decide what's
right for your organization. As a general rule of thumb, a healthy
turnover rate is somewhere between the two extremes - one that will
invigorate your organization, but not undermine its ability to achieve
its objectives.
This article is brought to you compliments of Central Michigan Staffing
© 1998. All rights reserved.
|
|